StrictlyCome

  • Subscribe to our RSS feed.
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Digg

Monday, September 2, 2013

Let them eat mussels - National Post

Posted on 9:25 PM by Unknown

Jamie Oliver is promoting a new television show called “Jamie’s Money Saving Meals,” and a new cookbook called “Save With Jamie in the U.K.” You might think this would be a cakewalk for him: After all, the 38-year-old celebrity chef has published 17 previous cookbooks and hosted 25 previous TV shows and specials, many of which have focused on eating well on a budget. But something went terribly wrong during this week’s publicity blitz: Oliver suddenly began insulting the very people he was trying to market his new products to, and once he started saying condescending things he couldn’t stop.


First, in an interview with the Radio Times, Oliver derided the poor for watching TV and eating fast food instead of cooking healthy meals for themselves. “I’m not judgmental, but,” he began — a phrase which, like “I’m not a racist, but” or “I’m not homophobic, but” is a surefire indication that the clause to follow will prove the first clause false. This was certainly true in Oliver’s case; he went on to say: “I’ve spent a lot of time in poor communities, and I find it quite hard to talk about modern-day poverty. You might remember that scene in [Oliver’s previous TV series] Ministry of Food, with the mum and the kid eating chips and cheese out of Styrofoam containers, and behind them is a massive f**king TV. It just didn’t weigh up” … I just want to hug them and teleport them to the Sicilian street cleaner who has 25 mussels, 10 cherry tomatoes, and a packet of spaghetti for 60 pence, and knocks out the most amazing pasta. You go to Italy or Spain and they eat well on not much money. We’ve missed out on that in Britain, somehow.”


Oliver seemed to be referring to an antiquated, romanticized notion of Italian dietary habits: A study of young Italians’ eating habits in this month’s edition of the academic journal Appetite notes “a decline … among the young ‘traditionals’ who stand out for their high consumptions of fruit, vegetables and fish,” and a couple of years ago NPR explained Italians’ abandonment of traditional fare by noting wryly that these days, “you have to be wealthier to eat like a poor Mediterranean peasant.” In any case, British commentators seized not on Oliver’s outdated view of Italian eating but on his implication that Britain’s poor are too stupid, lazy, or hedonistic to value healthy eating over entertainment.


Perhaps the best rebuttal to Oliver’s contemptuous generalization came from the Guardian’s Alex Andreou, who writes that he has lived “in affluent and destitute circumstances — and every shade between the two,” and blasts Oliver’s poverty tourism. Andreou’s explanation of the psychology of poverty is illuminating:


“What I had not understood before I found myself in true poverty, and what Oliver probably does not, is that it means living in a world of ‘no.’ Ninety-nine per cent of what you need is answered ‘no.’ Ninety-nine per cent of what your kids ask for is answered ‘no.’ Ninety-nine per cent of life is answered ‘no.’ Cinema? No. Night out? No. New shoes? No. Birthday? No. So, if the only indulgence that is viable, that is within budget, that will not mean you have to walk to work, is a Styrofoam container of cheesy chips, the answer is a thunderous ‘YES.’ ”



In an interview with Good Housekeeping, Oliver ridiculed young Brits for whining about a 48-hour workweek



Rather than admit that perhaps shooting a few reality shows in poor communities did not make him an expert on habitually living without enough money, Oliver piled on by insulting young Britons’ work ethic. In an interview with Good Housekeeping, Oliver ridiculed young Brits for whining about a 48-hour workweek, called them “wet behind the ears,” and compared them unfavorably to migrant workers, saying “I think our European immigrant friends are much stronger, much tougher.”


Oliver’s gaffes are evidence that he is not the right person to try to teach working-class people good eating habits, nor, I would argue, is anyone who doesn’t actually have any personal experience of poverty. Upper-middle-class foodies should certainly work toward changing the food system and improving access to healthy foods in impoverished neighborhoods. But swooping in with television cameras to save the day — as Oliver has — is not the way to do it.


One of the few British newspapers to come to Jamie Oliver’s defense this week was the Independent, whose columnist Grace Dent argued that Oliver is entitled to his arrogant opinions about poor people. Dent is right — Oliver is entitled to his opinions. But he’s not entitled to the position of culinary hero for a population he disdains.


Slate.com


Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to FacebookShare to Pinterest
Posted in Entertainment | No comments
Newer Post Older Post Home

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Popular Posts

  • Katie Holmes Wears A Wedding Dress On Set Of Her New Movie - Huffington Post
    If you're reading this, Tom Cruise, worry not. Your ex-wife Katie Holmes is not remarrying for real, she's only donned this wedding...
  • Austin YMCA: Fall into new shoes - Post-Bulletin
    It's the end of August, and many of you are shopping for the school supplies, clothes and shoes. The shoes may be for everyday or a spor...
  • 20 life hacks to save you money and make your life easier - The Daily Telegraph
    Binder clips are an easy way to organise your cables. Picture: sillysimpleliving.com Source: Supplied FORGET the fancy gadgets and devic...
  • You can leave your shoes on: Speedy boarding coming to Colorado Springs ... - Colorado Springs Gazette
    For $85, people who frequently fly out of the Colorado Springs Airport will soon be able to breeze through security for the next five years ...
  • Jennifer Garner Shops for Shoes with Violet! - Just Jared
    Jennifer Garner [1] takes her daughter Violet [2] , 7, to pick up some new shoes on Tuesday (August 6) in Brentwood, Calif. The 41-y...
  • Something old, something new – Amy Huberman steps out in her wedding ... - Irish Independent
  • New York Today: Old-Fashioned Shoe Leather - New York Times (blog)
    Alyssa Loorya/ Chrysalis Archaeology If baby needs an old pair of shoes, look no further. Updated 12:54 p.m. | The excavation of this ci...
  • Ben Affleck steps into Batman's shoes - gulfnews.com
    He will star in the sequel of Man of Steel and will face off with Superman Reuters Image Credit: Evan Agostini/Invision/AP Actor/director B...
  • Celebrity Big Brother: The Cult Of Celebrity Choose Danielle To Join Ron In ... - Entertainmentwise
    The Cult of celebrity, AKA Louie Spence, Sophie Anderton and Lauren Harries, have chosen Dublin Housewives star Danielle Meagher to join fo...
  • Keep your shoes, jackets on: TSA to expand pre-screening program - CNN
    STORY HIGHLIGHTS The TSA will allow pre-screening at 60 more airports, expand it at 40 current airports PreCheck participants can skip re...

Categories

  • Entertainment (258)
  • Health (18)
  • Sport (44)
  • Technology (80)
  • Today Shoes (94)
  • Womens Athletic (4)

Blog Archive

  • ▼  2013 (498)
    • ▼  September (237)
      • Rocco Shoes Unveils the Latest Technology in Eleva...
      • 3D Print Everything: Printing Birdhouses to Violin...
      • Joe South, 'Walk a Mile in My Shoes' Singer, Dies ...
      • 3D Printed Shoes By Janne Kyttanen Turn Home Compu...
      • Parents, neighborhood get shoes for running grade-...
      • Eve's pain over Sex movie shoes - Hollywood.com
      • Jim Donaldson: Amendola, filling big shoes, hangs ...
      • At New York Fashion Week, designers mix it up and ...
      • Sarah Castille mounts an exploration of MMA - USA ...
      • Celebrity Super Spa: Beauty and the beasts - Daily...
      • Foot health - Another Cubs Blog (blog)
      • Jim Donaldson: Patriots' Amendola, filling big sho...
      • Midway through NY Fashion Week, designers say it's...
      • Designers Defy Matchy-Matchy Wisdom For The Mix - NPR
      • Jim Donaldson: Amendola, filling big shoes, hangs ...
      • Designers in New York keeping it simple with black...
      • Jim Donaldson: Danny Amendola, filling big shoes, ...
      • School library redo goes high-tech - Monitor Onlin...
      • Has Apple lost its mojo? - Kingston Daily Freeman
      • Designers defy matchy-matchy wisdom for the mix - ...
      • Man works to give Haitian kids a childhood he neve...
      • Designers defy matchy-matchy wisdom for the mix - ...
      • Mimi Naman: She sold lots of clothing, shoes and w...
      • New Angles on the Fast Track - New York Times
      • What It Takes To Get The New York Giants To An Awa...
      • Lady Gaga's latest outfit is actually very, very, ...
      • Julius, Jesus and Joshua - an unbeatable lineup - ...
      • Capacious closets - San Antonio Express
      • At Minkoff, Janelle Monae _ and fabulous footwear ...
      • At Minkoff, Janelle Monae _ and fabulous footwear ...
      • Pixie Lott, Union J, Louis Smith attend Nickelodeo...
      • Stars attend Nickelodeon Awards: Pictures! - Reveal
      • Why Do We Wear Sneakers Instead of Shoes on Yom Ki...
      • At Minkoff, Janelle Monae _ and fabulous footwear ...
      • Fairytale moment! Keira Knightley stuns in magical...
      • Shoe-stopping Moments - OK! Magazine
      • BIG SHOES TO FILL - STLtoday.com
      • BIG SHOES TO FILL - STLtoday.com
      • Technology comes to aid of wanderers - Newcastle H...
      • Toronto International Film Festival 2013: Labor Da...
      • From Myspace's Ashes, Silicon Start-Ups Rise - New...
      • From Myspace's Ashes, Silicon Start-Ups Rise - New...
      • At Minkoff, Janelle Monae _ and fabulous footwear ...
      • Strictly Come Dancing will waltz all over ITV's ne...
      • Double trouble! Jennifer Lopez juggles her twins w...
      • Technology comes to aid of wanderers - The Border ...
      • Martha Stewart Pushes Adorable Granddaughter in St...
      • Ballet prodigy gets a big lift from mom - The Japa...
      • At Minkoff, Janelle Monae _ and fabulous footwear ...
      • Kim Kardashian's Karl Lagerfeld photo shoot: Brill...
      • Fashionistas love the Janelle Monae concert and th...
      • At Minkoff, Janelle Monae _ and fabulous footwear ...
      • Notable Neighbor: Speedboats, celebrities and size...
      • 'You make things happen': The smoked meat, dog mas...
      • Kate Hudson Talks Shoes: Watch Here! - The Gossip ...
      • Boy's shoes duct-taped to his feet - ActionNewsJax...
      • Elaine Lui @ TIFF: A charming Brad Pitt bros down ...
      • Fashionistas love the Janelle Monae concert and th...
      • Shelby teacher headed to Peru to pass out shoes - ...
      • Bend Tech, Flexpoint Sensor Systems Receive Fundin...
      • When is it okay to wear sneakers with a suit? - Th...
      • Teammates pitch in to get friend new kicks after $...
      • At Minkoff, Janelle Monae _ and fabulous footwear ...
      • At Minkoff, Janelle Monae _ and fabulous footwear ...
      • Flexpoint And Bend Tech Announce Funding For Sport...
      • Shoe-stopping Moments - OK! Magazine
      • Community Calendar for the Midlands, Sept. 7 - The...
      • At Minkoff, Janelle Monae _ and fabulous footwear ...
      • Flexpoint And Bend Tech Announce Funding For Sport...
      • #1: Man Booker Prize Winner 2003 (Man Booker)
      • Boy's shoes duct-taped to his feet - ActionNewsJax...
      • At Minkoff, Janelle Monae _ and fabulous footwear ...
      • Flexpoint and Bend Tech Announce Funding for Sport...
      • At Minkoff, Janelle Monae _ and Fabulous Footwear ...
      • Dinner with the FT: Anya Hindmarch - Financial Times
      • Nick Nairn on his fall and rise as a celebrity che...
      • AP Photos: A few minutes of glamour, weeks of work...
      • How to choose running shoes - DesMoinesRegister.com
      • Six Things You Didn't Know about Firstborn's Top C...
      • AP Photos: A few minutes of glamour, weeks of work...
      • Serena Williams' shoes have custom US Open hearts ...
      • Footwear | Step into the right shoe - Livemint
      • From Naomi Campbell to this season's best shoes: t...
      • These Spiky Shoes Literally Put A Spring In Your S...
      • New York Today: Old-Fashioned Shoe Leather - New Y...
      • Why Not Treat CEOs More Like NFL Coaches - and Fir...
      • Halloween Costume Ideas 2013: 10 Celebrity And Pop...
      • Store Front Roundup: Running shoes delivered, yoga...
      • Flexpoint and Bend Tech Announce Funding for Sport...
      • Irina Shayk: XTI Shoes Stunner - The Gossip Girls
      • In light of the NSA, how to think about encryption...
      • Someone didn't check the forecast! Fearne Cotton b...
      • Tim's Travels: Chuck's Chucks - WMTV
      • Tim's Travels: Chuck's Chucks - WMTV
      • Flexpoint and Bend Tech Announce Funding for Sport...
      • British shoppers hoarding £4.67bn worth of unworn ...
      • Schools tech director leaving - Hernando Today
      • While Becks was partying at Bodo's Schloss in Kens...
      • Jason Wu: The American Dream - New York Times
      • Celebrity Spaces: Jackie Geary - Toronto Sun
    • ►  August (261)
Powered by Blogger.

About Me

Unknown
View my complete profile